Tomato and Goat Cheese Tart

I am by no means a vegetarian. The lard in the crust of my tart will give that away fairly readily. But one of my favorite cookbooks is called A Year in a Vegetarian Kitchen by Jack Bishop of the Cook’s Illustrated family. There is no deprivation in this book. It is pure comfort and joy. It celebrates the seasons and presents beautiful preparations for the bounty of each of them. I have integrated many of the recipes and ideas into my cooking. His recipe for a tomato tart obviously does not include the use of lard. And he takes other clever turns with his dough recipe that I have not included. The following is my “go to” dough recipe. The tart is heavily inspired by Bishop’s recipe, though, and he deserves the credit for this simple but flavorful combination. Think about it. It is crust, goat cheese, tomatoes, salt and pepper, olive oil, and fresh basil. That is all. It is good ingredients assembled thoughtfully and executed simply with a lovely result.

Tomato and Goat Cheese Tart
Recipe type: Entree
Serves: 6
Simple flavors in a lovely pastry crust.
The Crust
  • 1½ cups all purpose flour
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 4 tablespoons leaf lard (shortening if you do not have access to fresh lard)
  • ½ teaspoon salt (approximately…eyeball it)
  • 4 to 6 tablespoons cold water (a little more if needed)
The Filling
  • 6 ounces of goat cheese
  • 3 medium tomatoes (get the best…they are the star here)
  • extra virgin olive oil
  • salt and cracked black pepper
  • fresh basil leaves
  1. An hour before starting the crust, cut the butter and lard into small pieces and place them into a bowl in the freezer. Measure the flour and place it into a bowl in the freezer, as well. (I measure my flour into a re-sealable plastic bag and put it in the freezer. Leaf lard has a very long life in the freezer, so you should already have it there, as well. A pastry cloth is not necessary, but I now use one.)
  2. Place the butter, lard, flour and salt into a medium size bowl and work the flour into the fats with a pastry cutter or a fork, and then your hands. I sometimes use the food processor for a few pulses, but I always finish it up with my hands. Once the flour and fats are combined and you have worked the fats down to the size of peas, give or take, you can sprinkle the water on top and work it into the dough. When the dough is sufficiently moistened to hold together, stop. Wrap it in plastic wrap and shape it into a flat disk and put it into the refrigerator to rest for an hour or two.
  3. Preheat the oven to 375 degrees. Find a 9” tart pan with a removable bottom, or just adjust your ingredients to a different size pan. A 10" tart pan will accommodate up to 10 or so ounces of goat cheese. Changing diameter has a big impact on capacity.
  4. Slice the tomatoes, core them if needed, and lay them out on paper towels. Lay paper towels on top of them and press down very gently. Leave the tomatoes this way for a few minutes. The paper towels will absorb a lot of moisture and seeds.
  5. Meanwhile, remove the dough from the refrigerator. If it is too stiff to work, allow it to rest on the counter for a few minutes. Sprinkle flour on the counter or on your pastry cloth and roll out the dough to the approximate size, but a little larger, than the 10” tart pan. Ease the dough over to the tart pan and gently work it down into the corners (don’t stretch it). A handy way to cut off the excess is simply to roll your rolling pin across the top of the pan.
  6. Poke several holes in the dough with a fork. Take the goat cheese and crumble it into the bottom of the tart pan. Remove the paper towels from the tomatoes and place the tomatoes on top of the goat cheese in a slightly overlapping pattern. Save your prettiest slices of tomato for the top and squeeze any little or less lovely slices into blank spaces. Lightly drizzle olive oil on top of the tomatoes, and season them with sea salt or kosher salt and freshly cracked pepper.
  7. Bake until the edges of the tart are golden, about 45 minutes. Remove the tart to a wire rack to allow it to cool for a bit. Carefully remove it from the pan.

Note: My daughter, Lily, who does not like raw tomatoes, loves this tart. It is simple and basic. And, it is wonderful. It is also important to note that pastry can be a real pain sometimes. There are just days when it is not going to behave. Do not let the dough win. And, ugly tarts are good tarts, too. That is the entire reason behind the invention of the word “rustic,” I suspect.  It means kind of homely, but really tasty. So if your dough is being rude…tell it that you are in charge. Wad it up and start over if you have to. Piece scraps of dough into torn spots. Throw it back in the fridge for a bit if it is getting too soft. But, do not throw it away or quit. Just make it work and move on down the road. It is GOING TO taste great.

When the tart is to be served, adorn it with several fresh basil leaves. This can be eaten hot or at room temperature.

Also, I cannot overstate the importance of letting the tomatoes drain a bit on the paper towels. If you don’t, you can end up with a soggy bottom crust. The next time I make this I’m also going to lower my oven rack to the bottom third of the oven to get the bottom crust just that much closer to the heat element.

If you do not make pie dough often, consider reading the much more detailed instructions in my Quintessential American Apple Pie, Chocolate Pie with a Leaf Lard Crust, or Onion Tart post.


  1. Suzanne H says

    This looks divine. Once the local Hanover tomatoes come in season, I will have to try it. If you have not had Hanover (Virginia) tomatoes in your life, you are missing out! They are wonderful.

    I just found your site about 2 months ago and I love it. It’s so comforting and warm – like the food you make. And I can’t help but think of my 2 1/2 year old every time I read this site. I call him “Pie” (as in “Sweetie” or “Cutie”) so the name makes me smile!

  2. Kelly says

    I have never had the pleasure of tasting a Hanover tomato. I bet it is wonderful. I actually planted tomatoes this year for the first time and I can’t wait for them to start ripening. Thank you for your kind words about PIE. That means a lot to me. You should look up the Orange Julius Popcicles for your little Pie. Maybe too tart…but if he’s anything like mine, you will be making them every week. I’m glad to have you around!

  3. Suzanne H says

    Found the OJ recipe – if you recommend it, I’ll make it! I made the carrot cake you posted back in March – wow! Looking forward to the OJ pops – thanks.

  4. Allison says

    you have truly perfected pie/tart crusts!! I am envious – and HUNGRY just looking at the pics!

  5. Jane says

    Just picked beautiful Oregon tomatoes, can’t wait to get this into the oven before it gets too warm outside, will be beautiful for an early lunch! Thanks!

  6. Kelly says

    I can’t wait to hear how it turned out. I would bet that you have great tomatoes in Oregon. I just spotted the first of my Fall tomatoes and I’m so hopeful that they will get going before the weather gets too cold. They are my first Fall tomatoes. We shall see.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *